New Ulm and West Michigan were tied at 2-2 at the end of the third period. Fritz Belisle scored the game-winning goal at 1:09 into overtime with an assist from Mac Hankinson. Shots were 33-27 in favor of New Ulm.
New Ulm tied the game with a goal from Alex Egle at 17:17 into the first period. Assists were credited to Luc Kreuser and Fritz Belisle. Dylan Leivermann, assisted by Stephan Hermkes, scored at 17:36 into the second period on the power play to give New Ulm a 2-1 lead.
New Ulm totaled eight penalty minutes on four infractions and went 1-for-6 on the power play. West Michigan had a total of 14 penalty minutes on seven infractions and went 0-for-3 on the power play.